The Greatest Upset in Baseball History? Maybe not, but the Mighty Cubs did "learn a lesson or two"
The 1907 Cubs, who played at the West Side Grounds, were a formidable club. In 1906, the Cubs had gone 116-36 before losing the World Series to their cross-town rivals, the White Sox. In 1907, they'd fare better, winning 107 games and sweeping the Tigers in the World Series.
But two weeks before they took on the Tigers, they decided to pick up some extra cash by playing the Quincy Buds, a mediocre (.500) team that played in the I-I (Illinois-Iowa) League. It wasn't like the Cubs called up a bunch of minor leaguers to preserve their starters, like they do these days in such games -- six of their regular eight took the field. And this was saying something, considering the '07 Cubs boasted four future Hall-of-Famers: player-manager Frank Chance, shortstop Joe Tinker, second baseman Johnny Evers, and pitcher Mordecai Brown.
But on one day, in mid-September 1907, the Buds were better than the Cubs. The Quincy Daily Herald headline read: "THE CHAMPIONS EATEN ALIVE BY THE BUDS." The news story that followed began:
The Chicago stars badly beaten on the Quincy diamond and but for errors would have been shut out.
It was a nice tame little bunch of Cubs that the Buds chased around the lot yesterday. They let Mr. Hofer's men lead 'em around by the nose. They climbed the pole, danced, ate out of the hand and rolled over and played dead. Slats Rause's foolers were beyond them and after the first inning it was like taking candy from the children. The Cubs can lead the Nationals, but when they hit the Buds, they can climb a tree for they are out.
Chicago came to the bat first and Shorty Slagle made a safe hit to right field. Hofman the shortstop grounded to Johnson who made a neat and tidy error and gave Plummer a chance to fumble which he immediately proceeded to do and Slagle advanced to third in a hurry. Schulte flew west to Rudd and Patsy Moran hit safe to the left field Fisher fumbled the ball and both runners scored.
You can read the rest of the story at the Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County site.
Following the jump are a photo of the game and a video recounting the events of the day.












Recent Comments