The '27 Yankees or the '43 Grays? You decide.
The short but excellent documentary below, "Homestead Grays: Gone But Not Forgotten," has two stars: the Grays themselves, and author Brad Snyder, who tells much of the story that illuminates the silent footage. The Grays were based in Pittsburgh from 1910 to 1939, and moved to Washington, D.C. in 1940. Snyder argues, not in this documentary but elsewhere, that the 1943 Grays were at least as good as, if not better than, the great 1927 Yankees.
His argument has a lot of merit, and Snyder, author of the authoritative and popular team history, Beyond the Shadow of the Senators : The Untold Story of the Homestead Grays and the Integration of Baseball, knows of what he speaks. The 1943 Grays had a lineup that included the late, great Buck Leonard (often referred to as "the black Lou Gehrig"), Josh Gibson (who hit more dingers at Griffith Stadium in '43 than the entire Senators lineup), Cool Papa Bell, Jud Wilson, and ace Ray Brown, all Hall of Famers. While battling rivals like Satchel Paige's Kansas City Monarchs, the Grays won their ninth straight pennant that year and then defeated the Birmingham Black Barons in the Negro World Series.
and Ed Bouchee to the Chicago Cubs for Tony Taylor and Cal Neeman. It wasn't exactly a banner trade -- both the Phils and Cubs were second division teams, and neither would ride this exchange to a pennant.






Recent Comments